Breadcrumb
SERCC Newsletter: October 2026
Main navigation
- Writing Grants
- Writing Research Articles
- Writing Generally
- Why Clear Writing Matters
- Feedback Integration and Collaborative Authorship
- Biostatistics Resources Available to CCOM Researchers
- Branding and Style Guides
- Courses Relevant to Science Communication
- Intellectual Property and Commercialization
The Power of Feedback: Strengthening Your Scientific Writing Through Strategic Review
Writing is often viewed as a solitary endeavor, yet the strongest scientific documents are rarely produced in isolation. In this newsletter, we discuss the value of feedback and offer strategies for obtaining meaningful input that can enhance the impact of your work.
Why Feedback Matters
The purpose of getting feedback is not solely to identify and eliminate errors. As writers, we often become too familiar with our work to recognize gaps in logic or unclear explanations that a reader might not be able to follow. External reviewers bring fresh perspectives and can help answer critical questions, such as:
- Is the central message clear?
- Are the aims, hypotheses, and conclusions compelling?
- Does the narrative flow logically?
- Are key concepts explained sufficiently for the intended audience?
- Are any sections confusing, contradictory, redundant, or underdeveloped?
Good reviewers can also highlight strengths, helping authors distinguish what is working well from what needs more emphasis or clarification.
The Best Time to Solicit Feedback
A common misconception is that feedback should be sought only once a document is nearly complete. However, obtaining feedback at multiple stages of development is often more beneficial.
- Before a first draft is written: Seeking input during the conceptual stage can help refine research questions, specific aims, study design, and overall structure—even before significant time has been invested in writing. Feedback at this early stage often identifies potential gaps or challenges, circumventing the need for major revisions later.
- As a draft evolves: Writing brings ideas into focus. As sections begin to take shape, colleagues can evaluate the arguments for logic, the narrative for cohesion, and the evidence for its persuasiveness. Mid-stage reviews are particularly useful in preparing grants and manuscripts; as details are filled in, it may become necessary to revise the overall organization and messaging. However, keep in mind that if a draft is too underdeveloped, it may be difficult for a reviewer to provide useful feedback.
- Before a mature draft is submitted: Once earlier reviews have taken place, late-stage reviews can focus on clarity, completeness, consistency, and potential issues that could affect reviewer perceptions. This is also an ideal time for editing related to readability, grammar, formatting, and adherence to sponsor or journal requirements.
Whom You Should Ask for Feedback
Different reviewers offer distinct expertise. Consider incorporating feedback from a team of individuals with complementary perspectives.
- Subject Matter Experts: These may include mentors and senior investigators, such as colleagues with deep expertise in your field. They can evaluate the scientific rigor, significance, innovation, and methodological approaches in your writing and provide insights into reviewer expectations and proposal strategy. They can also provide guidance on positioning your work within the broader funding or publication landscape. For University of Iowa investigators, the Research Development Office (RDO) offers an External Grant Review service, which includes facilitating review by subject-matter experts.
- Collaborators with Related Expertise: These may include researchers in adjacent disciplines who may be better at identifying assumptions or jargon that would be unclear to broader scientific audiences. They may also comment on the logic of the organization and presentation of the writing or provide insight into the broader impact of your research.
- Professional Editors and Scientific Communication Experts: Editors can help improve the organization, readability, flow, consistency, and overall effectiveness of your scientific communication. They often bring a fresh perspective, identifying issues that authors and other scientific reviewers may overlook, including inconsistencies with funding agency guidelines, journal instructions, or review criteria.
- Artificial Intelligence (AI): AI can provide quick feedback on clarity, organization, and readability, as well as suggest revisions to improve flow, identify alternative wording, and check for alignment between different sections of the document. However, AI-generated feedback should be evaluated critically, as it is not always accurate and can make text sound generic. In addition, confidentiality concerns and institutional policies should be considered before sensitive data are uploaded. AI is most effective when used to supplement, rather than a replace, expert human feedback.
Making Feedback Most Effective
When requesting feedback, be specific about the type of input you are looking for. Providing reviewers with focused questions can ensure that the review process is efficient and results in clearer guidance. Instead of simply asking, "Can you review this?" consider including questions such as:
- Are the Specific Aims clear and compelling?
- Does the Introduction adequately establish significance?
- Is there evidence of high scientific rigor and reproducibility?
- Is the narrative difficult to follow, and if so, where?
- Is the level of detail appropriate for the target audience?
- What questions did you have after a first read?
Using Feedback Constructively
Using critiques constructively can be challenging, particularly after having invested substantial time and effort in a project. It can be helpful to view feedback as an opportunity to strengthen your work rather than a judgment of your abilities as a researcher or writer.
Of course, it isn’t necessary to incorporate every suggestion you receive. However, recurring comments from multiple reviewers often are a sign that a point warrants attention. Even if the specific suggestions for resolving the problem differ, revising such sections in some way will likely improve how future reviewers interpret your work.
A Final Thought
Writing is a fundamental form of communication between scientists, funding agency personnel, and the general public. Ultimately, the goal is not to simply document your research, but to convey ideas to others clearly and persuasively. Seeking thoughtful feedback throughout the writing process can transform a good document into an outstanding one, increasing the likelihood of funding and publication success. As such, the process will also expand the scientific impact and reach of your work.
Our office is available to assist researchers at all career stages with their grants, manuscripts, and other scholarly communications. We encourage you to contact us early during the writing process with any questions or requests for assistance.
Happy writing (and reviewing),
Jennifer Barr and the SERCC Team